Leave a comment:
Dear Spammers and Trolls: All comments are checked by myself before publishing!
The manual inspection is why it takes some time until your text appears in the comment section (as long as it passes my inspection) - be patient...

I don't answer comments by mail!
Note the rules and my mail address in the column contact!

Norbert

Name:
Comment:
Formular:


----------------------------------------------------

Page: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_en.htm
Date: 2018.10.23 22:00:44 (UTC+1)
Name: Alan

Comment:
:D

Me: Yes!



----------------------------------------------------

Seite: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_ge.htm
Datum: 2018.10.09 16:32:32 (UTC+1)
Name: Troll

Kommentar:
Lieber Nobbi,

du könntest ja auch mal Lego Mindstorms in deine CNC Reihe aufnehmen.

Me: Ich behalte Lego als Baumaterial mal im Hinterkopf. Die Mindstorms Steuerung mit den entsprechenden Motoren ist mir aber zu speziell. Ich baue lieber mit Zeugs, das ich in alten Geräten finde.
Ich könnte meine Meinung aber ändern, wenn Lego sich bei mir meldet und ne Kiste mit Elektronik zusendet ;-)

----------------------------------------------------

Seite: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_ge.htm
Datum: 2018.03.10 14:17:05 (UTC+1)
Name: bisichrisi

Kommentar:
Exestiert die Hardfaser-Maschine,von welcher ein kleiner ausschnitt zu sehen war, noch?
Mich würde interressieren welche Abmessungen diese Maschine hat. (Arbeitsbereich,...)

Me: Die hatte ich als Demo, ohne Funktion gebaut und mittlerweile wieder zerstückelt. 3mm Hartfaserplatten sind viel zu weich, als dass man mit einer derartigen Maschine was sinvolles anfangen könnte.




----------------------------------------------------

Seite: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_ge.htm
Datum: 2016.12.31 14:23:49 (UTC+1)
Name: Michi

Kommentar:
Super Maschine!
Was haben die Servos für Abmessungen?

Me: Danke!
Das sind Standard-Servos mit Standard-Abmessungen. Google nach "Standard Servo" und du bekommst alle Infos inklusive technischer Zeichnungen...

----------------------------------------------------

Seite: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_ge.htm
Datum: 2016.12.31 14:23:49 (UTC+1)
Name: Michi

Kommentar:
Super Maschine!
Was haben die Servos für Abmessungen?

Me: Das sind Standard-Servos mit etwa 41x20x40mm.

----------------------------------------------------

Page: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_en.htm
Date: 2016.11.28 05:36:22 (UTC+1)
Name: Andrew

Comment:
Hi again,

In my class of 8 groups we've finished 3 models. 5 more to go, although one group may have given up.

I had an idea to simplify the design. Instead of using epoxy on the threaded rod to make a switch, how about cutting the round servo horn (or inserting a pin) to make a cam?  The cam can move one paperclip to touch another one (like the limit switch). It makes the operation more obvious, and requires less work to make.

I may do this if I have time. I could use the abandoned model.

Me: Great to hear that you already turned 37.5% of your students into real engineers. I am sure you won't give up until you got all of them ;-)
Inserting a pin on the servo horn (maybe a screw) is a good idea, that might save build time. Let the world (and me) see it in operation.
Thanks again for sharing your thoughts!

----------------------------------------------------

Page: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_en.htm
Date: 2016.11.08 02:02:35 (UTC+1)
Name: Andrew

Comment:
Just a quick update.  First, 1.3mm card is no problem.  Also, is it worth adding the approximate cut-length of the threaded rod to your instructions?  I estimated X=120mm Y=140mm and Z=100mm.  A little longer is okay, and the length does not have to be accurate.  Do you agree?

My students have done 2 classes so far.  Each class is 1h10m.  Most groups have finished cutting.  Some groups have almost finished gluing.  My plan for 6 classes is: Cutting, Gluing, Motors, Switches, Wires, Software.

Me: Thanks for the update and for the remark about the cut length of the threaded rods. I have added that to the description. With the finished machines you can do more than one class programming the software. Since the Raspberry Pi has more computing power than the Arduino I was using, you can even teach algebra with the plotter software.

----------------------------------------------------

Seite: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_ge.htm
Datum: 2016.10.23 09:47:03 (UTC+1)
Name: Christian

Kommentar:
Geniale Arbeit!
Eine Frage zur Konstruktion aus Hartfaser-Platten(Video_5:45):
Weißt diese Maschine bessere mechanische Eigenschaften auf als CNC_v0_6?

Me: Die Hartfaserplatten-Maschine am Ende des Videos habe ich nie fertig gestellt. Die sollte nur als Demonstrationsobjekt dienen, ich bin aber gleich zur richtigen CNC v3.2 übergegangen. Besser als CNC v0.6 wäre die nicht geworden. Die 3mm Hartfaserplatten sind viel zu weich.

----------------------------------------------------

Page: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_en.htm
Date: 2016.10.17 03:53:42 (UTC+1)
Name: Andrew

Comment:
Thanks for fixing the numbers.  Green looks like light grey, so your numbers are now white with a light grey border.  They are much more visible when printed.  I would recommend in the future maybe green characters with a black border, but it is not necessary to change it now.

I have cut all of my pieces, and I acquired some 1 metre M3 threaded rod in Seoul.  Now I will start gluing!

Me: Good news, thanks for the feedback!

----------------------------------------------------

Page: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_en.htm
Date: 2016.10.13 12:28:17 (UTC+1)
Name: Andrew

Comment:
In Figure 17 you say "Attention!
X22 and Y22 have to be glued on the back side of this picture when using the CNC with servo drives!"

But, the photo indicates X28 and Y22. Is this an error? Do you mean "When using servos do not use X28. Use X22, and glue it and Y22 on the 'back' side of this picture."?

One more thing, sorry, when I print your photos in black and white the labels are hard to see.  Green is printed as pale grey, just like the background.  Maybe use a font with an outline?

Me: Yes, it must be X28 and Y22 in the text besides the photo. I have corrected that.
I will see what I can do to give the numbers a better visibility in grayscale prints - it's no quick fix...
Thanks for your feedback!

----------------------------------------------------

Page: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_en.htm
Date: 2016.10.12 09:29:28 (UTC+1)
Name: Andrew

Comment:
I have started to build this. By which I mean I have printed the artwork and I am cutting the pieces. I live in Korea, but I can not get 1.5mm card here. However I can get 1.3mm card, so I am using that. I also do not have M3 threaded rod yet.

I am hoping to build this with some my Korean students (I teach English here). I will make one, and show them the video. Then I hope they will be excited to build one too. I have 18 students, so I will make six models with teams of three.

Me: Great to hear about your project. The 1.3mm cardboard should work, too. It's no high precision machine, just a demonstration of how things work in principle.
Hope to see your machines running, soon.



----------------------------------------------------

Page: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_en.htm
Date: 2016.10.09 23:22:32 (UTC+1)
Name: munching

Comment:
Hi Norbert,

A simple and stupid question: should the the templates be printed on A4 or A3 paper?

Thanks.

Me: It's Din A4.



----------------------------------------------------

Seite: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_ge.htm
Datum: 2016.09.05 10:46:38 (UTC+1)
Name: Christian

Kommentar:
Geniales Projekt !

Eine paar Fragen zu der Konstruktion aus Hartfaserplatten(Video 5:45):
Wie hast du die Hartfaserplatten, welche z.b. als Führungen dienen, senkrecht verklebt?

Wie präzise ist die Mechanik dieser Konstruktion?

Wird ein Video zu dieser Maschine folgen ?

Danke im Voraus
Christian  

Me: Die Hartfaser-Maschine habe ich nur auf die Schnelle zusammengeklebt, um zu zeigen, wie die große CNC in etwa aussehen wird. Das Material ist viel zu weich, um als Basis einer CNC zu dienen, daher gibt's dazu eher kein Video...


----------------------------------------------------

Page: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_en.htm
Date: 2016.08.17 22:38:25 (UTC+1)
Name: Wrt_usa

Comment:
I got some cardboard form a GE packing box.
The spacer user to hold the appliance in place are a
hard dense cardboard with a cross section that looks like this

___     ___
[  \___/  ]
\---------/

you can fit then together to from a low fiction slider.
I going to saw them instead of cutting the with an egsacto knife.
I got about 7 of them.

Thanks Wrt_uas

Me: Sometimes the packing is as interesting then the package content.




----------------------------------------------------

Page: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_en.htm
Date: 2016.08.05 02:49:34 (UTC+1)
Name: Wrt_usa

Comment:
Right I working on the write for my machine.
Can I included the link to you project page.
I have see other videos on these type of cnc machines.
You a mush better job of explain these machines.

Thanks
Wrt_usa

Me: I'd be pleased if I can insert the link to your project. No matter what way you publish your work, simply make it public so that all people can start to improve the design - that's the idea of open source movement.



----------------------------------------------------

Page: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_en.htm
Date: 2016.08.04 07:30:43 (UTC+1)
Name: Wrt_usa

Comment:
I need to get a better camera.
I'm working on a improve control program.
I'm going to try to make a real simple g code program.
I was using putty to control my cnc machine today.
It worked. I sure I can get around of the weakness with software.
It using a low power TI launchpad board for the controller.

Thanks

Me: More ambient light would give better results even with this camera.
I did not expect that you would put that much effort in your build - I am impressed!
Hope to see a video of your CNC, because there is nothing more exciting than watching interesting machines running ;-)

----------------------------------------------------

Page: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_en.htm
Date: 2016.08.03 01:06:32 (UTC+1)
Name: Wrt_usa

Comment:
MY picture are on the way.
I included a sample trace I did today.
The trick is to keep the machine moving.
I need to work on a better control program.
When I was talking to a friend about my cnc machine.
He told me I should add lever switch. This gives me a resolution of around 1/52 of an inch.
Yeh English measurements.
The output looks fairly good, so I going to try tracing out parts on cardboard and project board.

You still make the best videos on this stuff.
thanks
Wrt_uas
 
Me: Your pictures arrived - thanks! So you were definitely not the guy of the "no subject" mail...
The academical resolution is nothing if the backlash is larger than 1/52 of an inch which is around 1/2 of a millimeter ;-)
Hope to get a video with the machine running.
The effort put in my videos is worth every minute as long as makers like you keep watching them.


----------------------------------------------------

Page: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_en.htm
Date: 2016.08.02 20:13:24 (UTC+1)
Name: Wrt_usa

Comment:
Hey I got my version of a cnc machine running now.

Me: I guess it was you that send me a mail with two pictures of your CNC, but without a subject and no name ore something else that could make me remember who you are ;-)
Is there a YouTube video of the running machine?

----------------------------------------------------

Page: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_en.htm
Date: 2016.07.16 00:04:18 (UTC+1)
Name: Sasha

Comment:
You did not mention how much wire and what kind is needed, and do I need to solder the wires.   :)
Also the electrical diagram is not clear enough for someone without knowledge in this area.

Me: Buy lost of wire - you never have enough for this and future projects ;-)
If the electric diagram isn't clear enough, learn to read electric diagrams - I can't beam the knowledge in your brain ;-)



----------------------------------------------------

Page: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_en.htm
Date: 2016.06.29 17:02:58 (UTC+1)
Name: Ricardo

Comment:
Grettings, i have three questions:
- Is the diode used to not let the curent in a wrong way?
- What problems we could have in not using the diode?
- Which diode fit for this project?

Thanks for share this amazing project!

Me: Yes, the diode is just to avoid wrong polarity. You can use any diode with a continuous current of 500mA or more.

----------------------------------------------------

Page: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_en.htm
Date: 2016.05.21 17:28:34 (UTC+1)
Name: Pk. D

Comment:
Congratulations on completion of this amazing project.This indeed looks like I could build it in a few months. I have already started to get the cardboard gathered up. BTW, what does this mean: Total costs around 60,- €, 5,-€ with manual operation. This page says that in the product list.
Thanks!

Me: Arduino + Servos + batteries + charger is around 60,-€. Well, if you don't buy cardboard or treads and nuts, you can get the manual version for (nearly) free...




----------------------------------------------------

Page: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_en.htm
Date: 2016.05.17 06:40:11 (UTC+1)
Name: Wrt_usa

Comment:
I run in to problems with libraries having differences.
There are some Arduino libraries that will only work for AVR chips.
If you lucky you can find the problem code and work around it.
I surprised that the Arduino based IDE works as well as it dose on the ChipKit and Launchpads.
The board have very different microtrollers, for the most part they can run Arduino C++ code.
Libraries hard to follow to, you get lost in code.

Thanks

Wrt_uas

Me: ...but libraries make programming so much easier. There are years of programming in the Arduino IDE and libraries, that's what many companies offering microcontroller boards simply can't do, thus they simply try to make it Arduino compatible. Since they usually even haven't enough man power to test all Arduino libraries, failures are inevitable. That's why the original Arduino / Genuino boards are the better choice.

----------------------------------------------------

Page: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_en.htm
Date: 2016.05.15 23:01:05 (UTC+1)
Name: Wrt_usa

Comment:
Ok

I did look at the servo library code after I commented last.
They wrote the code so there a constant pules with.
I found a min pulse value of 544 us and a max of 2400 us like you mention in your servo video.
The servo.write command only takes integer values degrees between 0 and 180.

The Energia Servo library has a Servo.readMicrosecond command that not in the Arduino Servo library.

Thanks
Wrt_uas

Me: For most applications the servo.write is all you need. I did not know about the Energia Servo library, but keep it in mind - thanks for sharing your thoughts.

----------------------------------------------------

Page: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_en.htm
Date: 2016.05.14 19:02:40 (UTC+1)
Name: Wrt_usa

Comment:
I built a test platform, it works and I'm work out the control for the servo motor.
Have you ever gone and look at the code into the servo.h library.
As I understand it analog servo operation between 50Hz and 60Hz.
The code for example sweep program

myservo.write(pos): // pos is 0 to 180
delay(15): //fulls out the rest of the pulse

If they putting a pin high and low again, there a change that pluses are not there same length.
thanks
Wrt_usa

Me: Creating pulses having EXACTLY the same length is not necessary. Just keep the error below a given pulse width. A hobby servo with a potentiometer as sensor won't be able to follow a variation less than an arcminute, thus an error of one arcminute won't really trouble your servo control.


----------------------------------------------------

Seite: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_ge.htm
Datum: 2016.05.09 16:57:24 (UTC+1)
Name: lennard thiele

Kommentar:
kanns´t du dazu etwas programmieren womit maneigene graphiken plotten kann?

Me: Können, ja, aber ich sehe da keinen allzu großen Sinn dahinter (ist halt recht zeitaufwänding). Diese CNC ist sehr langsam und mehr als einen Buchstaben zu Plotten ist kein Vergnügen...


----------------------------------------------------

Page: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_en.htm
Date: 2016.05.08 04:10:10 (UTC+1)
Name: Wrt_usa

Comment:
TI Launchpads have a different jumper set up than the Arduinos.
The pin names are the same for the special function pins.
There a sub-directory there has all the micrcontroller parts defined,
anything that connected to micrcontroller also has a definition.
ChipKit dose the same thing.
As long as you don't need to do anything that requires direct hardware access you can write code for all 3 platforms.
TI want to use the TI launchpads because they have a low power micrcontroller.
Thanks
Wrt_usa

Me: That sounds interesting, but I have no time nor money to try another board for my physical computing chapters, thus I will stay at the Arduino platform for my machines.
If you have build a copy of my machines with that TI board, send me a video link.

----------------------------------------------------

Page: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_en.htm
Date: 2016.05.07 03:28:45 (UTC+1)
Name: Wrt_usa

Comment:
I modified a servo for continuous rotation.
It works but it hard to stop it moving.
I'm using a Texas Instruments (TI for short) Launchpad MSP-EXP432P401R to drive the servo
Launchpads are TI answer to the Arduino, they around half the price of the Arduinos.
TI was smart and made a Arduino base IDE called Energia.
As far as I can tell Energia functions the same as Arduino IDE
wedsite http://www.ti.com/ww/en/launchpad/launchpads-msp.html#tabs

thanks
Wrt_usa

Me: The question is, if the code is compatible and you will have to figure out, what pin belongs to the same functionality at the Arduino. If it doesn't work, I won't be able to assist you with your problems, since I don't own a TI board. If you are an expert in microcontrollers you will be able to save some dollars, if not, you will buy lots of problems...

----------------------------------------------------

Page: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_en.htm
Date: 2016.05.02 at 07:15:20 (UTC+1)
Name: Wrt_use

Comment:
I am thinking of cutting slots out of a cardboard strip.

_-_-_-_-_-_ like this and passing thought one of the cdrom sensor I have.

This would be position information, no direction information.

I am sure it would work.

Thanks

Me: Thus you are going to implement a linear positioning sensor - interesting! Motion sensing is the subject I am currently working on. More about it in the  "Anything moves!" section on the Hackaday page:
https://hackaday.io/project/10299-self-replicating-cnc-for-194-or-more-countries
The video will follow, soon.



----------------------------------------------------

Page: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_en.htm
Date: 2016.04.29 at 23:37:56 (UTC+1)
Name: Wrt_usa

Comment:
I have some project board, servos and a bunch of micro switches of the cdroms.
So I going to them for a demo machine like to one you made.
The cdrom motors and printer motors I have are for better machines.

I make my encoder wheels out the tops of cat foods cans.
The metal real thin, cuts real easy.
Just hot melt to cdrom sensor together and you ready to go.

I looking forward to what you come up with next.

Thanks

Me: Hope to see your machine, soon. Some pictures or a link to a YouTube video would be nice.
How to detect motion will be treated in the next video about my 3.x CNC series.

----------------------------------------------------

Page: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_en.htm
Date: 2016.04.29 at 03:37:46 (UTC+1)
Name: Wrt_usa

Comment:
I been follow your stuff.
I started making my own cnc machine.
keep it up!

Thanks

Me: Would be nice to see your machine soon.


----------------------------------------------------

Seite: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_ge.htm
Datum: 2016.04.27 um 18:27:18 (UTC+1)
Name: Heinz Müller

Kommentar:
Viele Dank für dieses tolle und einfache Projekt! Es zeigt das komplexe Themen auch einfach gezeigt werden können. Ich habe schon einige Projekte nachgebaut und bin begeistert! Bitte mehr Projekte!
Viele Grüße

Me: Bitte Videos oder sonstige Links zu den Nachbauten!

----------------------------------------------------

Page: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_en.htm
Date: 2016.04.23 at 17:40:25 (UTC+1)
Name: Dave Hartmann

Comment:
This is fantanstic!
Is it possible to replace the servos with steppers while utilizing the same arduion code?

Regards,
Dave

Me: No, stepper motors need different electronics and so changes in the software code. I will create CNCs driven by (bipolar) stepper motors in the 3.x series. Maybe I will adapt the code to run on an Arduino only (without another host computer). Let's see what future brings...

----------------------------------------------------

Page: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_en.htm
Date: 2016.04.23 at 15:59:32 (UTC+1)
Name: José Fonseca

Comment:
Amasing! Simply amasing! Your work is much more valuable then the one of many teachers in schools. All these step by step tutorials are realy good and with lots of (in)formation. You are born to teach! CONGRATULATIONS!!!

Me: Thanks, and tell your friends and teachers about my project.

----------------------------------------------------

Page: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_en.htm
Date: 2016.04.16 at 17:04:45 (UTC+1)
Name: Ira

Comment:
Hi Sir..

Check your inbox..
Hope the info I sent will be usefull for somebody :)
More.. soon :)

Me: I am checking my inbox regularly ;)


----------------------------------------------------

Page: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_en.htm
Date: 2016.03.31 at 21:45:45 (UTC+1)
Name: Ira

Comment:
Hello sir,

I have salvaged parts from a Canon printer (photosensors, gears “to be used in your cnc v2.0”) with resistors calculation  I will send pictures and more info to your e-mail  soon..

Me: That would be nice!


----------------------------------------------------

Seite: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_ge.htm
Datum: 2016.03.29 um 10:14:19 (UTC+1)
Name: UNBEKANNT

Kommentar:
Hallo

Ich wollte nur fragen ob die CNC V3.0 mit einem Arduino oder per Raspberry PI angesteuert wird.

Was wird genau als Antriebsspindel der XYZ Achsen benutzt. Gewindestangen mit M6,M8 oder M10 Gewinde oder wird etwas Anderes mal ausprobiert.

Zum Späteren Design wäre ein Mix aus Rot,Grau und Blau gut. Dann hat es einen Metall Look.

UNBEKANNT

Me: Es wird eine CNC v3.0 bis 3.9 (oder so) geben, d.h. verschiedene CNC Maschinen mit einem Grunddesign, aber aus verschiedenen Materialien (Holz, Kunststoff, Metall). Ebenso wird es verschiedene Antriebe geben mit unterschiedlichen Motoren, Gewindestangen und in den Topmodell(en) Trapezspindeln.
Wenn ich von Design schreibe, dann meine ich mehr so die Hardware-Konstruktion an sich, nicht die Farbe ;-)


----------------------------------------------------

Seite: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_ge.htm
Datum: 2016.03.28 um 19:35:41 (UTC+1)
Name: schnipp

Kommentar:
Ich habe bisher Ausschlachtmotore aus alten Plottern,Druckern sowie Kopierern der 80er90er genutzt
Daten der aktuell genutzten sind 0.9Nm nema23
Die in neueren Geräten zu finden ist schwer.
Empfehle daher eher Das closed loopsystem mit stärkeren pollin DC-Motoren und sich die H-brücken mit z.B MJE3055
und MJE2955 (bis zu 150W) zu löten.

Aber werd erstmal abwarten,was der Erfinder sich so ausdenkt

Me: Ja, zumindest in den niedrig- bis mittelpreisigen Druckern neuer Bauart sind "nur" Gleichstrommotoren mit Photosensoren zu finden, aber die sind ja nicht uninteressant.
Mal sehen, wieviel Ampere die so ziehen und dann über entsprechende H-Brücken sinnieren. H-Brücken selber Löten ist aufwendig wenn man Sicherungen gegen zu hohen Strom, Kurzschluss und Shoot Through einbauen möchte und ohne Sicherungen birgt  die Verwendung einige Gefahren in sich...
Mal sehen, was so geht. Im Augenblick bin ich dabei eine Modell-Mechanik aus Hartfaserplatten zusammenzukleben. Danach geht's an die Elektronik.
Der "Erfinder" hat noch längst nicht alles gedacht was zu denken ist, daher werden Anregungen weiterhin gerne entgegengenommen ;-)

----------------------------------------------------

Seite: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_ge.htm
Datum: 2016.03.28 um 16:14:45 (UTC+1)
Name: schnipp

Kommentar:
Zitat:
4. Die Maschine soll die Teile zur Anfertigung einer Kopie seiner selbst fräsen können (Selbst replizierend)
Zitat ende:
Dazu sollte der Vorschub der Achsen um den Faktor 5-10 erhöht werden.
(Vermutlich ist dies der Grund,weshalb die Maschine aus 6mm Sperrholz entstehen soll.)
Hab jetzt alle Varianten einmal durch.Am besten geht die 2.1 in Pvc bis 25mm sowie Alu -8mm bei Zustellung 2mm bzw 0,6mm (jeweils 150mm/min)
Holz möchte so 1200mm/min,sonst iss'es mehr ein....äh Brandschneiden.
LG

Me: Die Geschwindigkeit zu erhöhen steht recht weit oben auf meiner Liste, aber die Grenze setzen die Motoren. Mal sehen, was ich in meinen alten Druckern so finde. Mit Motoren aus dem Versandhandel geht's auf jeden Fall besser.
8mm Alu? Hätte ich dem Ding gar nicht zugetraut. Man benötigt natürlich einen leistungsstarken Fräser mit wenig "Schlag".
Brandschneiden? Ja, damit habe ich gewisse Erfahrungen gesammelt ;-)
Holz ist natürlich nie gleich Holz...
Danke für deine Erfahrungswerte!


----------------------------------------------------

Seite: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_ge.htm
Datum: 2016.03.26 um 09:03:07 (UTC+1)
Name: schnipp

Kommentar:
Mir persönlich,gefällt ja die DC-Motorvariante sehr gut,weil man da mehr Auswahl hat und rel. leicht, höhere Drehzahlen bzw.Drehmoment realisieren kann.

Wie wäre es, das Prinzip der Führung von der v2.xx zu übernehmen?Dazu könnte man an die Auflage,sowie an die Unterseiten der Platten dieses 20x20
(oder kleiner)Winkelprofil schrauben.Weniger Reibung sowie Spielärmer.
Als Lager könnte man die (überall billig im  zu bekommenden Inlinedinger 22x8x9mm nehmen
Das wäre so mein Vorschlag
LG

Me: Das "closed loop" Prinzip bei den DC-Motoren sorgt dafür, dass keine Schritte ausgelassen werden können, was enorm wichtig ist. Habe mir schon ein paar kaputte Drucker besorgt, die ich demnächst auseinandernehme.
Die Führung wird derart geändert, dass die Schienen umschlossen werden d.h. Oben und Unten befinden sich Kugellager (der Vorschlag mit den Inliner-Lagern ist gut). Die selbstzentrierende Variante mit den im 45 Grad Winkel verbauten Führungen der 2.x Maschinen wird aber durch plan aufliegende Profilleisten bzw. Platten ersetzt.

----------------------------------------------------

Seite: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_ge.htm
Datum: 2016.03.25 um 14:50:56 (UTC+1)
Name: schnipp

Kommentar:
Na ich bin gespannt wie'n Flizzebogen,was da diesmal rauskommt.
Wird an der Mechanik was geändert,z.B.bezgl. der Führung?
LG

Me: Ich bin da genauso gespannt. Es werden verschiedene Maschinen mit unterschiedlichen Führungen und Antrieben dabei herauskommen. Vorschläge werden entgegengenommen, daher auch die Teilnahme am HackadayPrize2016 - ich erhoffe mir möglichst viel Feedback von deren Community und auf rege Beteiligung aller Leser auf meinen Seiten.


----------------------------------------------------

Page: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_en.htm
Date: 2016.03.25 at 09:49:06 (UTC+1)
Name: Pk. D

Comment:
Good job and best of luck for the HackaDay Prize!
Maybe this CNC will be possible for me to build - ur other ones are way too good and materials are not available here, but this one's description says it will be made of easy to find materials available in almost all countries at affordable prices.
So danke and best of luck!

Me: It will be more than just one CNC, but all based on (more or less) one design. There will be a high quality machine using ball screws, bipolar steppers and a metal frame that sets the reference. The idea is to get as close as possible with a variety of materials and drives. A local printer repair shop gives me the unrepairable devices, thus I can do some investigations about what parts to salvage from those gold mines.
Hope to see you CNC one day!

----------------------------------------------------

Seite: technics-machines-cnc-v3-0_ge.htm
Datum: 2016.03.24 um 15:08:51 (UTC+1)
Name: UNBEKANNT

Kommentar:
HALLO,

Also die Maßen auf dem Plan der CNC V3.0 wirkt 5mm oder 6mm Sperrholz sehr dünn. Erstens 8-12mm Sperrholz saugen Holzlack gut auf und weichen dann nicht gerade so viel auf und 8-12mm sind stabiler. Während bei 5 bis 6 Millimeter Ist das schon recht instabil. Holzlack empfiehlt sich auch gut wenn man mal Plastik schneidet und ein paar Tropfen gegen das Holz spritzen.
Also der Plan ist trotz allem gut.
Sperrholz ist eine Gute und schöne Material Wahl.

Viel Spaß noch beim Bau !

Me: Besten Dank für die Rückmeldung.
Der "Plan" ist momentan noch kein wirklicher Plan, sondern mehr so ein Platzhalter. Bezüglich des Materials werde ich verschiedene Versuche unternehmen. Bei Sperrhols mehr als 10mm ist in jedem Fall zu empfehlen und gegen Wasser zu schützen macht auch Sinn. Ich habe im Keller 3mm Hartfaserplatten rumliegen. Daraus werde ich die Tage erst einmal einen "Dummy" basteln, um ein grobes Design vorstellen zu können. Ab dem Zeitpunkt bin ich für weitere Vorschläge offen.